top of page

Chicken Barb & Steak Tips in Merrimack Valley

Writer: Adam Horvath
Adam Horvath
9 minutes ago
3 min read

It's entirely possible that someone has lived their entire life in Merrimack Valley Massachusetts and has never heard of a Chicken Barb. Yet in Methuen and Lawrence, literally INSIDE that same Valley, it's practically part of their vocabulary and has been for decades. This is the perfect definition of hyperlocal.


Barb, colloquially pronounced "bahb," 'cause things are pronounced differently in New England, has nothing to do with BBQ, despite the spelling. It's actually a shredded chicken sandwich, slowly simmered in a well-seasoned stock and served warm on a hamburger bun with a leaf of lettuce and a dollop of mayo. It's moist, but not wet.


From a distance, it could pass for a chicken salad sandwich. But don't let its simplicity fool you. The slow braise gives the chicken a rich, savory flavor reminiscent of a steaming bowl of chicken noodle soup. One bite and you're home sick from school, still in your pajamas, watching The Price Is Right. And that random leaf of lettuce? Turns out it's not just some afterthought garnish. It's there to provide the textural crunch the melt-in-your-mouth chicken needed.


Chicken Barb sandwich on a bun
Chicken Barb sandwich on a bun

Herman Marggraf's Tally Ho Inn is often credited with inventing the sandwich sometime in the 1940s, but I'm not asking anyone to take a paternity test. The sandwich eventually found its way onto other local menus, including Jo Gile's Bungalow in Lawrence and Norm's White Horse in Methuen.


Sadly, those three neighborhood favorites are long gone, but their culinary legacy lives on.


Mann Orchards Farmstand has them etched onto its country lunch menu, right next to its homemade pies and freshly picked apples. But the go-to spot to scratch your Barb itch has to be Pica's Pub and Grill, a lively local hangout where the food is just as good as the drinks.


And I'll tell you what, it doesn't get much more New England than waiting for a beer, two deep at a bar, while some guy in a tattered Sox cap yells out over your shoulder... “Hey, hon, lemme get a bahb and an order of tips!”


Just the Tips


Steak tips at Pica's
Steak tips at Pica's

A few weeks earlier, I wouldn't have known what the hell that guy was ordering. But a 2 a.m. rabbit hole researching New England foods had brought me to Pica's for precisely that reason. In this part of Massachusetts, steak tips are everywhere. But according to Tom Doyle, fourth-generation co-owner of Alpine Butcher in Lowell, as quoted in Boston Magazine, a true New England steak tip can only come from one cut of beef: sirloin flap.


What am I, a vampire?
What am I, a vampire?

I fumbled my order with the Pica's waitress, who seemed surprised to learn that people from Jersey don't eat steak tips. Within minutes, I was staring down five glistening chunks of perfectly charred beef.


Despite my well-documented apathy toward steak, I was excited to dig in. The knife slid effortlessly through the tender meat, revealing a pink center much rarer than I'm accustomed to. But when in Rome—or however they pronounce it here.


The marinade delivered a burst of Italian dressing flavor, followed by just enough chew to remind me I was eating a dead cow. Before I'd even swallowed, I instinctively reached for another forkful.


Listen, I'm not suggesting we carve the Chicken Barb and steak tips into New England's culinary Mount Rushmore. But if you ever find yourself stuck in "rush"-hour traffic on the Loop Connector, take the exit into Methuen.

And honestly, I'm not entirely sure the tips don't deserve a spot up there.



For a fascinating look at the mysterious origins of New England steak tips, I highly recommend Rachel Leah Blumenthal's deep dive for Boston Magazine. It's well worth the read.


SUBSCRIBE VIA EMAIL

  • Facebook

Thanks for submitting!

© 2020 by Foodigenous Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page